Sovereign Grace Ministries Board Declares C.J. Mahaney Fit, Returns Him To Office Of President

January 24, 2012 in Sovereign Grace Ministries

[Kris says:  Earlier today, I received a document entitled Review Process Reasoned Reports Package.  What follows is what appeared on the first two pages of the “Package.”   It appears that SGM plans at some point in the near future to make the entire report available as a PDF.]

Announcement Regarding C.J. Mahaney

from the Sovereign Grace Ministries Interim Board of Directors

In July 2011, Sovereign Grace Ministries (SGM) installed an interim Board of Directors.  Our primary task was to determine C.J. Mahaney’s fitness to serve SGM as President in light of accusations made against him by a former SGM leader, Brent Detwiler.  To accomplish this, we sought to apply the teaching of 1 Timothy 5:19-21 regarding the examination of an elder.  As described in our October 28 blog post, we created three panels to review Brent’s allegations and report their findings to us, after which we would determine if C.J. was to continue in his role as President.

After examining the reports of these three review panels, we find nothing in them that would disqualify C.J. from his role as President, nor do they in any way call into question his fitness for gospel ministry.  Therefore the Board has decided unanimously to return C.J. to the office of President, effective immediately.

These reports confirm the experience of many people over many years under the ministry of C.J. Mahaney.  C.J. is a man and a minister of fundamental integrity who has endeavored to serve SGM with faithfulness and humility since its inception.  As with all ministers of the gospel, C.J. is not infallible, and this fact is not lost on him.  And so we also affirm that throughout this process of evaluation, C.J. has made genuine confession to the appropriate parties and has demonstrated a desire to grow in areas of weakness.  C.J. has demonstrated a commendable trust in the grace and sovereignty of God throughout this entire process.

To put our decision in context, shortly before the interim Board began its work, C.J. took a voluntary leave of absence to avoid even the appearance of influencing his evaluation.  To further protect the integrity of the process, the interim Board sought the counsel and affirmation of an outside conciliation ministry, Ambassadors of Reconciliation (AOR).

With C.J. on leave and AOR involved, the review process took the following form:  We commissioned three outside ministers to review Brent’s documents in light of C.J.’s confessions and render their judgment on his fitness to serve in ministry.  In light of their evaluation, they found him to be completely fit to serve.  We then commissioned three panels – each consisting of three SGM pastors – to evaluate C.J.’s involvement in the three central events of Brent’s allegations.  The panels had complete autonomy to interview any witness and review any evidence.  They conducted their reviews and prepared their reports without any outside influence, save for the oversight of an independent facilitator who was responsible to certify the process.  As readers will see in the reports, the panels had broad license to issue any individual or organizational recommendations they deemed appropriate in light of their findings.  They did an exceptional job with their unenviable assignment and we’re grateful to them for the many hours they invested in this process.

This has been a trying season for our family of churches and for C.J. and his family in particular.  The recommendations made by the panels delineate some of the weaknesses we see in our ministry, and we expect to learn even more when the separate AOR-led Group Reconciliation process is completed this spring.  Our hope and prayer is that all of us evaluate these matters humbly, apply the forgiveness that comes through the gospel appropriately, and relate to one another about these matters graciously as we work together to reform what needs reforming, reaffirm the goodness of God in our midst, and continue to plant and build local churches with our chief aim the glory of God through the gospel.

[Kris says:  The report continues for 51 pages, with the following Table of Contents:]

  1. Statements from the Review Panel Facilitator
  2. Report on C.J. Mahaney’s Fellowship
  3. Report on Brent Detwiler’s Dismissal from Grace Community Church
  4. Report on Larry Tomczak’s Departure from Sovereign Grace Ministries
  5. Sovereign Grace Board’s Response to the Reports
  6. Biblical Principles Informing this Process and Our Conclusions
  7. Final Comments on the Life and Ministry of C.J. Mahaney